Maroc - EURASIAREVIEW.COM - A la une - 13/Sep 16:04

Shaping ASEAN’s Future: Cooperation Between Indonesia And Singapore – Analysis

The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) is a crucial factor in the political and economic landscape of Southeast Asia. Among its ten member countries, Indonesia and Singapore hold distinct yet influential leadership positions that shape the direction of the bloc's development. Indonesia, being the largest and most populous country in ASEAN, often asserts itself as the natural leader of the region. Conversely, Singapore leverages its advanced economy and technological capabilities to exert significant influence. However, the competition between these two nations, along with their differing political and economic priorities, poses challenges to the cohesion and effectiveness of ASEAN. Addressing these challenges and promoting closer cooperation between Indonesia and Singapore is vital in ensuring that ASEAN maintains a powerful and unified role on the global stage. By aligning their policies, addressing differences, and working towards common goals, Indonesia and Singapore can unlock ASEAN's potential and strengthen the bloc's central position in regional and global affairs. Indonesia has long positioned itself as the leader of ASEAN, drawing upon its size, population, and economic strength. As one of the five founding members of ASEAN, Indonesia played a crucial role in shaping the organization's early policies and initiatives, particularly in the realms of regional security and diplomatic cooperation. Throughout its history, Indonesia has often served as a mediator in disputes within the region, and its emphasis on sovereignty and non-alignment has influenced ASEAN's stance on global issues. Under the leadership of President Joko Widodo, Indonesia continues to advocate for a more self-reliant ASEAN, one that prioritizes local economic development and regional autonomy. Indonesia's leadership in initiatives such as the ASEAN Highway Network and ASEAN Power Grid reflects its commitment to fostering increased connectivity and cooperation within the region. Economically, Indonesia holds the position of the largest economy within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), boasting considerable natural resources and a growing manufacturing sector. However, its focus primarily on domestic matters has occasionally hindered its full embrace of ASEAN's more ambitious regional integration endeavours, leading to the perception that Indonesia prioritizes its internal affairs more than other member states. In stark contrast, Singapore's leadership within ASEAN is firmly established in its economic and diplomatic capabilities. The city-state enjoys highly developed financial infrastructure, advanced technological systems, and renowned status as a global trade centre, providing it with a distinct advantage within the region. Continuously advocating for enhanced economic integration within ASEAN, Singapore actively champions initiatives such as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) and the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP). Additionally, Singapore plays a pivotal role in ASEAN's digital economy, driving innovation in areas such as financial technology, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity. Given ASEAN's aspiration to position itself as a hub for technological advancement and digital transformation, Singapore's leadership in the digital sphere holds particular significance.  Diplomatically, Singapore has long served as a vital link between ASEAN and major global powers including the United States, China, and the European Union. With its advocacy for balanced foreign policies, Singapore strives to safeguard ASEAN's autonomy while simultaneously fostering economic ties with these larger economies. However, despite these complementary strengths, the leadership roles of Indonesia and Singapore in the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) are often characterized by competition and tension. Indonesia's focus on regional autonomy and sovereignty frequently clashes with Singapore's advocacy for open markets and global integration. This divergence is particularly evident in their economic policies. While Singapore has embraced free trade and foreign investment, Indonesia's more protectionist approach, especially in sectors like agriculture, mining, and technology, creates friction. Trade disputes between the two countries, as well as diverging regulatory frameworks, have hindered the full realization of ASEAN's economic potential. For instance, Singapore's highly developed regulatory environment for data privacy and cybersecurity sharply contrasts with Indonesia's fragmented and inconsistent regulations in these areas. Such regulatory disparity complicates cross-border collaboration, particularly in the digital economy where robust data sharing and security measures are crucial. The competition between Indonesia and Singapore is apparent in their political strategies. Indonesia's emphasis on sovereignty and non-interference often puts it at odds with Singapore's more pragmatic approach to global diplomacy. This difference became evident in ASEAN's response to the South China Sea disputes. Indonesia's calls for a stronger and more unified stance on territorial sovereignty faced resistance from Singapore, which sought to avoid antagonizing China due to its economic interests. This divergence in foreign policy strategies weakens ASEAN's ability to present a cohesive front in dealing with external powers, thereby diminishing its centrality in regional security discussions. Despite the challenges faced, there are opportunities for Indonesia and Singapore to enhance their leadership roles within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) through a focus on cooperation rather than competition. One promising area for collaboration is the digital economy. By aligning their strategies in this domain, Indonesia and Singapore have the potential to drive ASEAN's technological transformation, enabling the region to become a global leader in financial technology (fintech), artificial intelligence (AI), and digital infrastructure. Singapore's technological expertise, coupled with Indonesia's significant market, creates the potential for synergies that can benefit the entire region. Joint investment in digital infrastructure, particularly in underserved areas in Indonesia, can bridge the digital divide and ensure a more equitable distribution of the benefits of digitalization across ASEAN. Additionally, both countries should focus on harmonizing their regulatory frameworks to facilitate greater economic integration. Bilateral agreements on data privacy, cybersecurity, and digital trade would reduce barriers to cross-border collaboration and create a more conducive environment for businesses operating within ASEAN. Indonesia and Singapore can also take the lead in promoting ASEAN-wide standards for digital governance, setting an example for other member states to follow. To maintain ASEAN's centrality in global affairs, Indonesia and Singapore must collaborate to present a unified front in engaging with external powers. Through coordination of their foreign policies and alignment of their diplomatic strategies, these two countries can strengthen ASEAN's position as a key player in regional security and economic negotiations. Achieving this objective necessitates regular high-level dialogues between Indonesian and Singaporean leaders to address differences and find common ground on critical issues such as the South China Sea, trade negotiations, and security cooperation. In conclusion, although Indonesia and Singapore each possess valuable qualities for ASEAN's leadership, their competition and differing priorities sometimes undermine the effectiveness of the bloc. To maximize ASEAN's potential, both nations must prioritize cooperation over competition, emphasizing areas where their strengths complement one another. Through collaborative endeavours to align their economic and political strategies, Indonesia and Singapore can establish ASEAN's role as a unified and influential force in the region and beyond. Their cooperation in the digital economy, infrastructure development, and regional security will be instrumental in ensuring that ASEAN retains its central position in global affairs. By fostering strategic partnerships and sharing a vision for the future, Indonesia and Singapore can guide ASEAN toward greater prosperity and stability in the years to come. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's own. References ASEAN Secretariat. ASEAN Digital Integration Framework Action Plan (DIFAP) 2019-2025. Jakarta: ASEAN Secretariat, 2019. Chia, Siow Yue. "Singapore: A Hub for Southeast Asian Economic Integration." In Southeast Asia in the Global Economy: Securing Competitiveness and Social Protection, edited by Shujiro Urata, 41-57. Singapore: ISEAS Publishing, 2011. Dosch, Jörn. ASEAN Economic Cooperation and Integration: Progress, Challenges, and Future Directions. New York: Routledge, 2014. Jones, David Martin. "ASEAN's Imitation Community: Security and Sovereignty in Southeast Asia." International Relations of the Asia-Pacific 9, no. 1 (2009): 5-29.